WHO IS THE SUBCONSCIOUS?

A philosophical exploration of human consciousness, the subconscious, learned identity, collective influence, and the origins of free will.



WHO DOES CONSCIOUSNESS QUESTION ITSELF THROUGH?


Learned Identity, Collective Influence, and the Origin of Free Will


Consciousness Within Consciousness

When human beings question their own thoughts, they must also question the consciousness that examines those thoughts. Consciousness cannot step outside itself and observe itself from an external position. The one who questions and the one being questioned exist within the same state of being.

Yet a deeper question emerges:

Consciousness processes information and becomes informed through the information it processes. But what is the will that divides consciousness into categories such as consciousness, subconsciousness, higher consciousness, collective consciousness, or other domains?

Who makes this distinction?

If consciousness claims that it is divided into separate sections, where does the authority originate that establishes the boundaries between them? Is it not consciousness itself that defines what we call the subconscious and positions it outside the conscious mind?

Therefore, the real question facing humanity is not how many parts consciousness contains. The real question is the identity of the will that draws the boundaries between these parts.

Human beings create concepts to explain their own minds. Then they accept these concepts as natural components of their mental structure. Gradually, the boundary between the one who defines and the thing being defined disappears.

When someone says, “My subconscious thinks this way,” who is speaking? Is it consciousness, which claims to know the subconscious, or another layer expressing information learned about the subconscious as its own thought?

A cycle emerges here: consciousness defines itself, learns its own definition, and then interprets itself again through that acquired definition.

When a person claims to know themselves, do they truly know themselves, or are they repeating definitions they have been taught?


Human Beings Awaken Within an Identity Given to Them

When a human being enters the world, not a single decision concerning their identity has been made by themselves. They do not choose their name. They do not determine their clothing. They do not decide which language they will speak, which culture they will grow up in, or which behaviours society will define as right or wrong.

From the very first day, an environment makes decisions on their behalf.

No baby is presented with five names and asked:

“Which one do you want?”

Their parents choose their name. They buy their clothes. They determine their colours. The colours, behaviours, and expectations society considers appropriate for girls and boys enter the child's world before the child develops an independent preference.

Pink is associated with girls, blue with boys. Toys, clothing, words, and behaviours take shape within this distinction.

Before a child evaluates colours within their own world of meaning, they learn what those colours are supposed to mean. Before developing a preference, they are presented with preferences.

Then they grow up.

One day, they say they like blue, prefer certain clothes, or enjoy particular behaviours. They believe these are entirely their own choices.

Yet an important question remains:

Who first formed that preference? The child, or those who made decisions on the child's behalf?

Human beings begin to live decisions made before their own existence as though those decisions were expressions of their personal will.

This is not merely a matter of names, colours, or clothing. Beliefs, fears, habits, values, ways of thinking, and life choices pass through the same process of transmission.

One generation passes on what it has learned to the next. The next generation accepts this inheritance as the starting point of its own life. Then it transfers what it has learned to another generation.

Thus, human beings do not simply live their own lives; they also continue decisions that began before them.

Generations change, yet the source of decisions often remains unchanged.


The Distance Between Learning and Knowing

When a person learns something, they acquire information about it. However, possessing learned information does not mean knowing its source.

Learning and knowing are not the same.

Learning is the arrival of information in the mind. Knowing is questioning where that information originated, under what conditions it was formed, and what place it occupies within one's own thinking.

A person can carry a thought for years. They can defend it, pass it on to others, and make it part of their identity. Yet they may never have questioned its original source.

Adopting a thought does not mean choosing it through free will.

Not every thought within the human mind originates from the individual. Some thoughts come from family, others from society, education, or the environment in which a person lives.

As human beings repeat these thoughts, they become personal. Information whose source has been forgotten begins to sound like one's own voice.

This is where learned identity emerges.

People assume that they consist entirely of their thoughts. Yet a significant part of those thoughts entered their lives before they had the opportunity to make their own decisions.

Therefore, knowing oneself is not simply knowing what one thinks. It also means questioning why one thinks that way and who first established that thought.


The Learned Language of the Body

Learned decisions do not remain confined to the mind. The body also carries the traces of repeated choices.

People repeat certain movements while writing, brushing their teeth, holding objects, or walking. Over time, these movements become habits. Eventually, habits turn into behaviours performed without conscious thought.

Consider a person who predominantly uses their right hand. They use it when writing, eating, brushing their teeth, and performing everyday tasks. Their left hand remains less involved. The same pattern appears in the use of the right and left feet.

But is the continuous use of one side and the reduced use of the other merely a matter of preference?

When a person begins brushing their teeth with their left hand, they move beyond an established habit. The body's familiar pattern changes. Attention becomes active again. The brain must manage a movement that has not yet become automatic. What initially feels difficult develops through repetition.

The important point here is not simply learning to use the left hand. It is reactivating an area of one's own body that has remained underused.

Within my Resonance Theory, the difference in continuous usage between the right and left sides of the body represents an important area of imbalance in terms of bodily integrity. The constant activation of one side and the reduced functional participation of the other must be examined as a matter that affects the body's overall operating patterns over time.

Within this theoretical approach, the long-term consequences of unilateral use are not limited to muscular and movement habits. Neural coordination, circulatory regulation, and organ function are also examined as interconnected elements of the whole.

I also theoretically investigate the relationship between this imbalance and cardiovascular disorders, heart attacks, strokes, and neurological dysfunction. This is not a claim of an established medical cause-and-effect relationship, but one of the central propositions of my theory that requires further investigation.

Human beings should not define their bodies solely through the side they use. They must rediscover the less-used side as an integral part of their existence and functional integrity.

Habits make certain movements easier while pushing other movements into the background. Over time, people begin to regard what they repeatedly do as natural rather than recognising the full range of what they are capable of doing.

Moreover, this pattern of bodily use does not begin entirely through personal choice. During development, children learn which hand to use more frequently, which movements to repeat, and how to direct their bodies. Repeated actions eventually become automatic.

Thus, just as in the mind, a learned structure develops within the body.

Human beings must question not only their thoughts but also the way they use their bodies. Every repetition that becomes a habit gradually determines how a person uses themselves.


Is an Unwanted Thought Really My Thought?

Sometimes a person encounters a thought within themselves that they do not want. A fear, prejudice, anger, or reaction inherited from the past suddenly emerges.

They reject the thought, yet cannot explain how it formed within their mind.

Then the following question arises:

Does the presence of a thought in my mind mean that it belongs to me?

Carrying a thought and choosing a thought are not the same.

A person can continue carrying a fear learned during childhood into adulthood. They can mistake a judgement inherited from their family for their own thinking. They can accept a boundary established by society as the boundary of their own will.

At this point, free will becomes more than the ability to make decisions.

Free will is the power to question the origin of a decision.

Human beings should not ask only, “What do I want?”

They must also ask:

“Who first created this desire? Where did this thought come from? Did I genuinely choose this decision, or am I simply continuing a choice that was presented to me?”

Because what a person considers their own thought is sometimes the voice of the past speaking through the present.


Free Will: Questioning the Decision Before the Decision

For a decision to be free, the ability to choose at the moment of decision is not sufficient. One must also question who created the available options, who established the boundaries, and what information shaped those preferences.

If a person is presented with only two options and chooses one, that choice does not represent the entirety of their will. The options themselves have already been determined by another will.

Freedom does not begin with choosing one of the options presented.

Freedom begins with questioning who created those options and what information was used to establish them.

When a person traces the origins of their own thoughts, they encounter a structure established before their existence. This structure begins within the family, expands through society, passes from generation to generation, and reproduces itself within the individual's identity.

Within this transmission, human beings become both carriers of the past and determinants of the future.

What they were taught yesterday, they teach someone else today. Decisions once made on their behalf are now made by them on behalf of another person.

Thus, the same cycle continues.

As long as people believe they are living only through decisions that belong to them, they cannot see the source of this cycle. When they question that source, they begin to distinguish between their own will and the will inherited from the past.


Answer or Question, Question or Answer?

Countless definitions of consciousness have been developed. Concepts such as subconsciousness, higher consciousness, collective consciousness, and self-consciousness have been used to explain the human inner world.

Yet one question stands before all these definitions:

How does the consciousness that makes these distinctions explain the origin of its own decisions?

What criteria does consciousness use when classifying its own domains? Where does the information establishing these criteria originate? And where does the will evaluating that information stand in relation to the domains it defines?

The purpose of these questions is not to multiply the names given to consciousness. Their purpose is to reveal the will that consciousness uses when defining itself.

When questioning their own thoughts, human beings must also recognise that the one doing the questioning is influenced by learned information, past experiences, and collective transmission.

Thus, questioning moves beyond the content of thought and turns towards the source that forms it.

This is where the real breakthrough begins:

Human beings no longer question only what they think, but also how their thoughts came into existence.


CONCLUSION: THE RETURN OF CONSCIOUSNESS TO ITSELF

Human beings do not choose their identity at birth. They are called by a name given to them, grow up in a world determined by others, and begin to think within a language created by others.

Then they accept all of this as the natural starting point of their own lives.

Over time, they define what they have learned as thought, their habits as preferences, inherited values as beliefs, and the identity given to them as their own essence.

But this is precisely where human questioning must begin.

Without investigating the source of everything they consider their own, they cannot claim to fully understand their own will.

Consciousness processes information and becomes informed. Yet as long as it does not question the will through which it defines itself, it remains confined within the definitions it has learned.

If human beings want to understand their own consciousness, they must first investigate the inheritance of their thoughts. Because they were not the original authors of every decision that shaped them.

Human beings encounter their free will at the very moment they stop mistaking what was given to them for what they chose themselves.

And the fundamental question is now this:

Were the decisions that made me who I am truly made by me, or am I merely the continuation of decisions made before I existed?


ERCAN GÜNER 🌱

Cangunere.blogspot.com

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

THE BLİND SPOT OF COLLECTIVE INTELLIGENCE

İNANCIN ACI TOKATI

SUSKUNLUK